AUSTRALIAN SYNOD ALTERNATIVE Our priorities for 2026–2036
An independent Catholic lay initiative for the renewal of the Church in Australia

04

Evidence & stories

Protect Life in Australia

Data, real people and the choices society makes around vulnerability.

This page needs exceptional sourcing discipline. Official statistics, first-person testimony, medical and palliative-care material, and advocacy sources should be visibly labelled so readers can distinguish what is measured, what is reported and what is personal experience.

Signs of hope / effective action

Pressure / concern

Data / research / case

Video or audio

Evidence in the real world

Each item is labelled so readers can distinguish official data, research, testimony, reported cases and advocacy.

OFFICIAL DATA

1,082 Queenslanders died following VAD administration in 2025–26

Queensland’s independent VAD Review Board reported 2,256 first assessments, 1,963 eligibility findings and 1,082 deaths following administration of a VAD substance in the year to 30 June 2026.

Queensland Health · 2025–26

CASE + X LEAD

Annaliese Holland, 26: a young Australian VAD case that went viral

Annie Holland’s story spread widely on X. Adelaide University and Go Gentle confirm that she has lived with severe autoimmune autonomic ganglionopathy and publicly discussed her intention to access VAD.

Adelaide University / Go Gentle · 2026

OFFICIAL DATA

South Australia recorded 4,725 pregnancy terminations in 2024

The state reporting committee recorded 4,725 terminations, including 48 after 22 weeks and 6 days. The same report shows the overall rate was the lowest in 25 years — important context rather than a one-direction narrative.

SA Pregnancy Outcome Unit · 2024 report

PRACTICAL SUPPORT

Pregnancy support can be concrete, not merely rhetorical

Pregnancy Help Australia operates a national free helpline and support network. Pregnancy Assistance Frankston reported hundreds of calls and walk-ins in 2024 plus home visits and baby bundles.

Pregnancy Help Australia · 2024–26

CASE STUDY

Palliative care can radically change the experience of dying

Palliative Care Australia’s 2025 lecture compared one family’s two very different end-of-life experiences, using the deaths of two sons to show what worked — and what failed — in care systems.

Palliative Care Australia · 8 May 2025

VIDEO / DEBATE

▶

Watch both sides of a live policy question: VAD and telehealth

ABC 7.30’s 2026 interview with Andrew Denton provides a concise, primary-source argument for telehealth access in VAD. It belongs on the page precisely because evidence pages should expose readers to the strongest opposing case as well.

ABC 7.30 · 27 Jul 2026

Born alive after termination: testimony, records and the legal debate

Some of the most confronting evidence in this debate concerns babies showing signs of life after a termination. The material below separates firsthand testimony, official parliamentary records and the competing clinical and legal interpretation.

VIDEO / FIRSTHAND TESTIMONY

▶

Midwife Louise Adsett told Queensland Parliament what she had witnessed

At the 19 August 2024 parliamentary hearing, clinical midwife Louise Adsett said she had worked in maternity and birth-suite units for about 14 years. She described babies showing signs of life after terminations and gave two detailed examples, including one she said lived for about five hours and another for almost three hours. She distinguished what she had directly witnessed from incidents reported to her by colleagues.

Queensland Parliament public hearing · 19 Aug 2024

OFFICIAL PARLIAMENTARY RECORD

Queensland’s 2024 inquiry formally examined the issue

The Termination of Pregnancy (Live Births) Amendment Bill 2024 sought to state expressly that when a termination results in a person being born, existing duties to provide medical care and treatment still apply. The bill’s explanatory material cited Queensland perinatal data and stated that 328 babies had been recorded as born alive following termination procedures from 2010 to 2020.

Queensland Parliament / Queensland Legislation · 2024

CONTESTED INTERPRETATION

The dispute was not simply over whether signs of life can occur

The parliamentary committee ultimately recommended that the bill not be passed. Its report said health practitioners told the inquiry there was already no confusion about live birth and that babies born alive in Queensland already had legal protections. RANZCOG likewise argued that clinicians already owed the relevant duties and that legislating clinical decisions could adversely affect care. This is important context: the evidence includes a real dispute over whether the problem was absence of legal protection, consistency of practice, staffing and comfort care, or the need for a new statutory duty.

Queensland Parliament committee report / RANZCOG · 2024

This section should never hide the humanity of people facing abortion, disability, terminal illness or VAD. Catholic conviction is strongest when it combines moral clarity with practical alternatives, palliative care and visible support.

Editorial rule: X may surface leads and primary statements, but a material factual claim should not be published from a viral post alone. Confirm it with an official document, original reporting, court or agency record, research paper, or the named person or organisation. Where a dispute remains contested, show the competing account rather than implying certainty.